tray: remove tray-position = adaptive (#2726)

The tray is automatically started if there is a tray module. In addition, `tray-position` and the tray module conflict.

Ref #2689

include/components/bar.hpp

@@ -43,7 +43,7 @@ class bar : public xpp::event::sink<evt::button_press, evt::expose, evt::propert
 
   const bar_settings& settings() const;
 
-  void start();
+  void start(const string& tray_module_name);
 
   void parse(string&& data, bool force = false);
 

include/components/controller.hpp

@@ -100,6 +100,7 @@ class controller : public signal_receiver<SIGN_PRIORITY_CONTROLLER, signals::eve
   eventloop::loop& m_loop;
   unique_ptr<bar> m_bar;
   bool m_has_ipc;
+  string m_tray_module_name;
 
   /**
    * @brief Async handle to notify the eventloop

include/x11/tray_manager.hpp

@@ -39,8 +39,10 @@ class connection;
 class background_manager;
 class bg_slice;
 
+enum class tray_postition { NONE = 0, LEFT, CENTER, RIGHT, MODULE };
+
 struct tray_settings {
-  alignment align{alignment::NONE};
+  tray_postition tray_position{tray_postition::NONE};
   bool running{false};
   int rel_x{0};
   int rel_y{0};
@@ -61,7 +63,6 @@ struct tray_settings {
   rgba foreground{};
   bool transparent{false};
   bool detached{false};
-  bool adaptive{false};
 };
 
 class tray_manager : public xpp::event::sink<evt::expose, evt::visibility_notify, evt::client_message,
@@ -80,7 +81,7 @@ class tray_manager : public xpp::event::sink<evt::expose, evt::visibility_notify
 
   const tray_settings settings() const;
 
-  void setup();
+  void setup(const string& tray_module_name);
   void activate();
   void activate_delayed(chrono::duration<double, std::milli> delay = 1s);
   void deactivate(bool clear_selection = true);

src/components/bar.cpp

@@ -388,13 +388,14 @@ void bar::parse(string&& data, bool force) {
 
   auto rect = m_opts.inner_area();
 
-  if (m_tray && !m_tray->settings().detached && m_tray->settings().configured_slots && !m_tray->settings().adaptive) {
+  if (m_tray && !m_tray->settings().detached && m_tray->settings().configured_slots &&
-    auto trayalign = m_tray->settings().align;
+      m_tray->settings().tray_position != tray_postition::MODULE) {
+    auto tray_pos = m_tray->settings().tray_position;
     auto traywidth = m_tray->settings().configured_w;
-    if (trayalign == alignment::LEFT) {
+    if (tray_pos == tray_postition::LEFT) {
       rect.x += traywidth;
       rect.width -= traywidth;
-    } else if (trayalign == alignment::RIGHT) {
+    } else if (tray_pos == tray_postition::RIGHT) {
       rect.width -= traywidth;
     }
   }
@@ -872,7 +873,7 @@ void bar::handle(const evt::configure_notify&) {
   m_sig.emit(signals::ui::update_geometry{});
 }
 
-void bar::start() {
+void bar::start(const string& tray_module_name) {
   m_log.trace("bar: Create renderer");
   m_renderer = renderer::make(m_opts, *m_action_ctxt);
   m_opts.window = m_renderer->window();
@@ -900,7 +901,7 @@ void bar::start() {
   m_renderer->end();
 
   m_log.trace("bar: Setup tray manager");
-  m_tray->setup();
+  m_tray->setup(tray_module_name);
 
   broadcast_visibility();
 }

src/components/controller.cpp

@@ -267,7 +267,7 @@ void controller::read_events(bool confwatch) {
     }
 
     if (!m_writeback) {
-      m_bar->start();
+      m_bar->start(m_tray_module_name);
     }
 
     /*
@@ -593,6 +593,13 @@ size_t controller::setup_modules(alignment align) {
     try {
       auto type = m_conf.get("module/" + module_name, "type");
 
+      if (type == tray_module::TYPE) {
+        if (!m_tray_module_name.empty()) {
+          throw module_error("Multiple trays defined. Using tray `" + m_tray_module_name + "`");
+        }
+        m_tray_module_name = module_name;
+      }
+
       if (type == ipc_module::TYPE && !m_has_ipc) {
         throw application_error("Inter-process messaging needs to be enabled");
       }

src/x11/tray_manager.cpp

@@ -67,25 +67,26 @@ tray_manager::~tray_manager() {
   deactivate();
 }
 
-void tray_manager::setup() {
+void tray_manager::setup(const string& tray_module_name) {
   const config& conf = config::make();
   auto bs = conf.section();
-  string position;
+  string position = conf.get(bs, "tray-position", "none"s);
 
-  try {
+  if (!position.empty() && position != "none" && !tray_module_name.empty()) {
-    position = conf.get(bs, "tray-position");
+    m_log.warn(
-  } catch (const key_error& err) {
+        "The tray position is manually defined (`tray-position`) and also set by the tray module (%s). `tray-position` "
-    return m_log.info("Disabling tray manager (reason: missing `tray-position`)");
+        "will be ignored",
+        tray_module_name);
   }
 
-  if (position == "left") {
+  if (!tray_module_name.empty()) {
-    m_opts.align = alignment::LEFT;
+    m_opts.tray_position = tray_postition::MODULE;
+  } else if (position == "left") {
+    m_opts.tray_position = tray_postition::LEFT;
   } else if (position == "right") {
-    m_opts.align = alignment::RIGHT;
+    m_opts.tray_position = tray_postition::RIGHT;
   } else if (position == "center") {
-    m_opts.align = alignment::CENTER;
+    m_opts.tray_position = tray_postition::CENTER;
-  } else if (position == "adaptive") {
-    m_opts.adaptive = true;
   } else if (position != "none") {
     return m_log.err("Disabling tray manager (reason: Invalid position \"" + position + "\")");
   } else {
@@ -119,18 +120,20 @@ void tray_manager::setup() {
 
   auto inner_area = m_bar_opts.inner_area(true);
 
-  switch (m_opts.align) {
+  switch (m_opts.tray_position) {
-    case alignment::NONE:
+    case tray_postition::NONE:
       break;
-    case alignment::LEFT:
+    case tray_postition::LEFT:
       m_opts.orig_x = inner_area.x;
       break;
-    case alignment::CENTER:
+    case tray_postition::CENTER:
       m_opts.orig_x = inner_area.x + inner_area.width / 2 - m_opts.width / 2;
       break;
-    case alignment::RIGHT:
+    case tray_postition::RIGHT:
       m_opts.orig_x = inner_area.x + inner_area.width;
       break;
+    case tray_postition::MODULE:
+      break;
   }
 
   if (conf.has(bs, "tray-transparent")) {
@@ -801,9 +804,9 @@ void tray_manager::process_docking_request(xcb_window_t win) {
  */
 int tray_manager::calculate_x(unsigned int width) const {
   auto x = m_opts.orig_x;
-  if (m_opts.align == alignment::RIGHT) {
+  if (m_opts.tray_position == tray_postition::RIGHT) {
     x -= ((m_opts.width + m_opts.spacing) * m_clients.size() + m_opts.spacing);
-  } else if (m_opts.align == alignment::CENTER) {
+  } else if (m_opts.tray_position == tray_postition::CENTER) {
     x -= (width / 2) - (m_opts.width / 2);
   }
   return x;